Crossover: IIR or FIR? - Printable Version +- Devialet Chat (https://devialetchat.com) +-- Forum: Devialet Chat (https://devialetchat.com/Forum-Devialet-Chat) +--- Forum: Tweaker's Corner (https://devialetchat.com/Forum-Tweaker-s-Corner) +--- Thread: Crossover: IIR or FIR? (/Thread-Crossover-IIR-or-FIR) |
Crossover: IIR or FIR? - Waiski - 24-Oct-2017 Thanks! Please read my message from here... https://devialetchat.com/showthread.php?pid=67403#pid67403 RE: Crossover: IIR or FIR? - watchnerd - 24-Oct-2017 (24-Oct-2017, 08:43)Waiski Wrote: Thanks! Wow...how weird. How was that tested? Was it using the subwoofer crossover output or the HP/LP filters for the speakers? Crossover: IIR or FIR? - Waiski - 24-Oct-2017 We did connect the measurement equipment directly to Devialet and did run test signals directly to computer. Guy who did the calculation does desing loudspeakers so he does know how to do this right. Crossover: IIR or FIR? - Waiski - 24-Oct-2017 We did connect the measurement equipment directly to Devialet and did run test signals directly to computer. Guy who did the calculation does desing loudspeakers so he does know how to do this right. Pre out and loudspeakers out does work the same way. RE: Crossover: IIR or FIR? - watchnerd - 25-Oct-2017 (24-Oct-2017, 13:07)Waiski Wrote: We did connect the measurement equipment directly to Devialet and did run test signals directly to computer. Okay, so this is at the pre-out, not at the speaker output, right? Crossover: IIR or FIR? - Waiski - 25-Oct-2017 Both. No difference. RE: Crossover: IIR or FIR? - watchnerd - 25-Oct-2017 (25-Oct-2017, 08:30)Waiski Wrote: Both. No difference. How certain are you guys of your test results? Because the algorithms are so widely known and commonly used it would take extra effort to screw them up in the way your measurements indicate. RE: Crossover: IIR or FIR? - thumb5 - 25-Oct-2017 For the hard of understanding, please would you explain why the measurements show the filters are "screwed up"? It didn't obviously read that way to me. Thanks. Crossover: IIR or FIR? - Waiski - 25-Oct-2017 Exactly. The filters are not screwed up. I'll send you more infomation later today. RE: Crossover: IIR or FIR? - watchnerd - 25-Oct-2017 (25-Oct-2017, 09:35)thumb5 Wrote: For the hard of understanding, please would you explain why the measurements show the filters are "screwed up"? It didn't obviously read that way to me. Thanks. This, from the other thread: "Order LP=>-6dB ... -6dB=>HP HP=>-6dB ... -6dB=>LP 1st 1.733 ... 0.577 2nd 1.000 ... 1.000 3rd 0.765 ... 1.307 4th 0.643 ... 1.556 So for 2nd order crossover you can use this without adjustments. 1000hz is 1000hz crossover point. But for example 1000hz 1st order crossover point are... low pass is 577hz and high pass is 1733hz. " It certainly doesn't fit the textbook definition. Textbook definition of a 1st order 1000Hz high/low pass filter should be 6 dB down at an octave interval, i.e. 500Hz and 2000Hz. |